CADDYCOMPARE

Wedge · 2023

Mizuno S23

The CaddyIndex™ breakdown: our rating across all six performance dimensions, researched from published expert reviews, online sentiment and our own weighting algorithm.

By the CaddyCompare editorial team · updated 9 June 2026

85CaddyIndex™
Scores foryour handicap · saved on this device
Mizuno S23

Performance index

Six researched ratings, lower (blue) through to elite (gold).

Forgiveness
82
Distance
85
Workability
86
Feel
91
Sound
88
Looks
85

Where it wins

  • Feel91
  • Sound88
  • Workability86

Watch

Forgiveness82

Rated highest for feel and sound; its softest dimension is forgiveness.

Fits your gameAll-round
set your handicap on the score above
Best for

You want a soft forged players' wedge with extra mishit consistency and a wide grind choice, and don't mind the heel-cavity look - around £130-150.

Avoid if

You dislike the heel cavity or want the absolute highest spin - the blade-style T24 or a higher-spin wedge suits better.

Pros

  • A buttery-soft one-piece Grain Flow Forged feel - a level above most wedges
  • A centred sweet spot delivers tied-first carry consistency and the tightest shot area in 2023 testing
  • 4th-highest spin in 2023 testing with HydroFlow wet-weather grooves
  • Four grinds (S, D, C, X) across 44-62 degrees for full shotmaking versatility

Cons

  • The unusual deep heel cavity is divisive at address
  • Spin is strong but not quite at the elite top of the category
  • A players' wedge - true game-improvement players want a cavity-back design

By dimension

82

Forgiveness

Excellent

Strong for a forged wedge - the S23 centres the sweet spot via a shortened hosel and a heel cavity that shifts mass toward the toe, giving better-than-expected results from mishits and a tied-first smallest carry drop-off with the tightest shot area in 2023 testing. More forgiving than a pure blade, aimed at players who want help.

85

Distance

Excellent

High, consistent spin - ranked 4th-highest for spin in 2023 and 4th for consistency, the centred sweet spot lengthening dwell time for more spin on full and partial shots, the HydroFlow micro grooves retaining spin in the wet. Among the more dependable forged wedges for spin and distance control.

91

Feel

Class-leading

Best-in-class - the one-piece Grain Flow Forged 1025 carbon steel gives a buttery-soft, pleasant feel that upholds the Mizuno reputation for great feel, the centred sweet spot and forged construction adding soft, precise feedback. Among the softest, most refined wedge feels on the market.

Sources

Dig into the independent expert reviews and lab tests that feed into how every club here is rated. Each one is worth reading in full — they carry the launch-monitor data, hands-on testing and detailed photography that paint the complete picture before you buy.

More Wedge ratings

Frequently asked questions

Who is the Mizuno S23 best for?

You want a soft forged players' wedge with extra mishit consistency and a wide grind choice, and don't mind the heel-cavity look - around £130-150.

Who should avoid the Mizuno S23?

You dislike the heel cavity or want the absolute highest spin - the blade-style T24 or a higher-spin wedge suits better.

What handicap is the Mizuno S23 suitable for?

The Mizuno S23 suits a broad range of abilities, from high-handicap beginners through to scratch and tour players.

What is the Mizuno S23 best at?

In our research the Mizuno S23 rates highest for feel and workability, and is softest on forgiveness.