CADDYCOMPARE

Fairway · 2023

Mizuno ST-Z 230

The CaddyIndex™ breakdown: our rating across all six performance dimensions, researched from published expert reviews, online sentiment and our own weighting algorithm.

By the CaddyCompare editorial team · updated 23 May 2026

75CaddyIndex™
Scores foryour handicap · saved on this device
Like new · eBay UK
£141.89
View deal →
Used · eBay UK
£129.99
View deal →
Compare 36 variants from 3 retailers
Mizuno ST-Z 230

Performance index

Six researched ratings, lower (blue) through to elite (gold).

Forgiveness
71
Distance
78
Workability
72
Feel
80
Sound
78
Looks
84

Where it wins

  • Looks84
  • Feel80
  • Distance78

Watch

Forgiveness71

Rated highest for looks and feel; its softest dimension is forgiveness.

Fits your gameAll-round
set your handicap on the score above
Best for

You're a low-to-mid HCP (0-18) at 85-110mph who wants a neutral, low-spin tour-aspirational fairway with classical looks and an adjustable hosel — comfortable trading lab-test forgiveness for confidence-inspiring straight ball flight.

Avoid if

You're a slicer who needs draw bias (look at the ST-X 230 / ST-Max 230 siblings), you swing 115+mph (you may balloon the ball), or you prioritise robot-test forgiveness metrics over reviewer impressions.

Pros

  • Won Golf Digest 2023 Hot List Gold — the head hides forgiveness behind a better-player address profile
  • Straightest 3-wood for 2023 per reviewer testing — laser-straight dispersion on halfway-decent swings
  • Reviewer testing measured 152 mph ball-speed average and 14th overall in independent robot-test distance ranking for 2023
  • 3rd-generation MAS1C maraging steel face hits 1.6mm — the thinnest face ever on a Mizuno fairway wood

Cons

  • Robot testing's Most Wanted ranking placed the head 27th overall, with accuracy and forgiveness scoring towards the bottom — a divergence from reviewer praise on forgiveness
  • Off-centre acoustic degrades to a dull thud — informative but less polished than the centred pop
  • Faster swingers may struggle to keep the ball down due to mid-low spin profile — better suited to moderate swing speeds
  • Now 3 years old — the brand's 2026 JPX One Tour sits above it in the current low-spin lineup

By dimension

71

Forgiveness

Solid

Reviewer testing: the head particularly impressed on off-centre strikes, with the ball rarely falling off line despite hitting off the toe — in indoor testing only one ball finished more than ten yards from the desired target line. The internal stabilising chamber provides additional sole flex to improve ball-speed retention on impact. The carbon composite crown lowers CG for higher MOI. However, independent robot testing places the head 27th overall with scores for accuracy and forgiveness finishing towards the bottom of those scoring categories — a stark divergence between reviewer testing (excellent off-centre retention) and robot testing (poor accuracy/forgiveness). Net above-average forgiveness in reviewer hands but data-test-poor in lab conditions.

78

Distance

Strong

Reviewer testing measured a 152 mph ball-speed average — premium for a 2023 fairway. Independent robot testing's Most Wanted ranking: 14th overall in distance — top-quartile in the 2023 fairway field. The 3rd-generation maraging steel face hits 1.6mm thickness — the thinnest face ever on a Mizuno fairway wood. The internal stabilising chamber adds energy return at impact for ball-speed support. Top-tier 2023 distance — among the best independent robot-tested categories for the head.

72

Workability

Solid

Reviewer testing: the head is the straightest 3-wood for 2023 — neutral CG, no imposed bias. Industry coverage: straight, stable and high launching — workable but defaults to straight. The centered CG on the Z-axis is engineered for neutral trajectory rather than draw or fade bias. 4° hosel range (13-20° effective via 15°/18° heads) lets skilled players dial in trajectory. Above-average workability for a high-MOI fairway — neutral CG plus shape-on-demand intent, even if straight is the default ball flight.

80

Feel

Strong

Reviewer testing: the feel on centre is powerful and explosive. Industry coverage: delivers a powerful, solid sensation at impact. The internal stabilising chamber's stainless-steel mass in elastomer creates more energy return, whilst moving weight closer to the clubface to reduce spin, and produce a more solid feel at impact. Off-centre feedback degrades quickly — when you miss the sweet spot, your hands will feel the strike location and a very dull impact. Above-average centred feel; informative-but-harsh off-centre feedback.

78

Sound

Strong

Reviewer testing: on centre, this club produces a mid-low pitched pop without any metallic notes. Leave the centre of the face, and the sound quickly turns to a dull thud. Reviewer testing highlighted awesome sound as a key pro. The internal stabilising chamber dampens unwanted vibrations that negatively impact the sound. Same on-centre / off-centre acoustic divergence as the 2021 ST-Z and 2022 ST-Z 220 — clean centred pop, dull off-centre thud. Above-average centred acoustic; informative off-centre.

84

Looks at address

Excellent

Reviewer testing: classic gloss black carbon crown that frames the ball perfectly at address — great address look that will appeal to a wide variety of players. Industry coverage: full, round shape, compact and player-ish appearance that gives an overall midsized impression. Industry awards 2023 Gold panel: the fairways likely fit a better player's eye, but they neatly hide the elements that allow them to play with the additional forgiveness average golfers need. Top-decile aesthetic for the 2023 fairway field — the head's strongest dimension.

Sources

Dig into the independent expert reviews and lab tests that feed into how every club here is rated. Each one is worth reading in full — they carry the launch-monitor data, hands-on testing and detailed photography that paint the complete picture before you buy.

We paraphrase and synthesise these sources; we don't republish them. Publishers can read how we use reviews or request a change.

More Fairway ratings

Frequently asked questions

Who is the Mizuno ST-Z 230 best for?

You're a low-to-mid HCP (0-18) at 85-110mph who wants a neutral, low-spin tour-aspirational fairway with classical looks and an adjustable hosel — comfortable trading lab-test forgiveness for confidence-inspiring straight ball flight.

Who should avoid the Mizuno ST-Z 230?

You're a slicer who needs draw bias (look at the ST-X 230 / ST-Max 230 siblings), you swing 115+mph (you may balloon the ball), or you prioritise robot-test forgiveness metrics over reviewer impressions.

What handicap is the Mizuno ST-Z 230 suitable for?

The Mizuno ST-Z 230 suits a broad range of abilities, from high-handicap beginners through to scratch and tour players.

What is the Mizuno ST-Z 230 best at?

In our research the Mizuno ST-Z 230 rates highest for looks at address and distance, and is softest on forgiveness.

Does the Mizuno ST-Z 230 have a shot bias?

The Mizuno ST-Z 230 is broadly neutral in shot shape (no built-in draw or fade bias), with a high launch and low spin.